Clinical Reviews
|
Weigh up risks and benefits of smoking cessation treatments
26 Apr 2012
A comparative study using data from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has found that the risk of depression and suicidal/self-harm behaviour is substantially greater with varenicline than with other smoking cessation treatments t(although the absolute risk of harm is low). Dr Phillip Bland, GP with an interest in mental health, Dalton-in-Furness assesses the import of this paper for UK primary care: I think it is reasonable to continue to offer varenicline as a first-line treatment, provided; we counsel patients to stop their treatment and seek immediate advice if they develop agitation, depression or suicidal thoughts; we closely monitor those with a previous history of psychiatric illness; we do not prescribe to high risk patients e.g. those with a previous history of attempted suicide; we liaise closely with smoking cessation services. I would advocate a shared-care protocol clarifying mutual responsibilities and the importance of passing on relevant information.'
Difference in BP readings between arms can predict outcomes in hypertension
25 Apr 2012
An inter-arm difference in systolic BP can predict cardiovascular morbidity and all-cause mortality after 10 years in patients with hypertension, a UK study in the BMJ has found. This cohort study was carried out in a rural general practice setting in Devon. It analysed 230 patients receiving treatment for hypertension; 47 of whom had cardiovascular disease at recruitment. The authors conclude that differences in systolic BP between arms can predict an increased risk of cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality over 10 years in patients with hypertension. They suggest that this could be used as another indicator of increased cardiovascular risk and furthermore that BP measurement on both arms should be performed as a matter of routine in primary care. ‘Assessment of BP in both arms is recommended by guidelines and should become a core component of initial BP measurement in primary care,’ the authors state.
Metabolic changes persist in older women with PCOS
25 Apr 2012
In patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) metabolic changes persisted and waist circumference increased over two decades of follow-up, although hormonal parameters improved, in a longitudinal study from Italy. Dr Chris Barclay, GP with an interest in O&G, Suffolk, commented on the study: 'The message I took from this paper is that although some of the manifestations of PCOS may abate with time the high risk metabolic abnormality underlying the condition (insulin resistance) does not.Women with PCOS should be viewed as a group at enhanced risk of CHD and type 2 diabetes and should be identified for preventative interventions. My first step in managing these patients is to advise a low-carbohydrate/low-glycaemic index diet to address their hyperinsulinism and insulin resistance.'
Male gender an independent predictor of mortality in heart failure
25 Apr 2012
Being male or having diabetes confers a poorer prognosis in patients with heart failure, a large meta-analysis in the European Journal of Heart Failure has shown. The authors used data from 31 studies in the Meta-Analysis Global Group In Chronic Heart Failure (MAGGIC) of 41,949 patients with heart failure of which 28,052 were men and 13,897 women. Dr Peter Savill GP Watercress Medical, Medstead, GPwSI Cardiology, Southampton, writes: 'The authors note that women with ischaemic heart failure present more like men probably because the effect of an acute event such as a myocardial infarction negates the degree of protection from being female unlike the more gradual process of a non-ischaemic cardiomyopathy. Furthermore, diabetes patients with heart failure are known to have a poorer prognosis and again less of a gender effect is seen.'
Which women should be offered ovary removal at hysterectomy?
25 Apr 2012
Researchers from the US have developed a risk score that could be used to quantify women’s risk of ovarian cancer and determine which patients should be offered prophylactic oophorectomy at the time of hysterectomy. A total of 1,098 women who developed invasive ovarian cancer were compared with 1,363 controls aged > 40 with no history or family history of breast or ovarian cancer. All completed a questionnaire.Several factors emerged as conferring higher risk of developing ovarian cancer. These were were: polycystic ovary syndrome or obesity, Jewish ethnicity, habitual application of talc to the genital area, dysmenorrhoea or endometriosis, less than one year’s use of oral combined contraception, no tubal ligation, no breast feeding and nulliparity. 'This study suggests that it may be possible to identify women at greater risk of future ovarian cancer who may be especially advised to have prophylactic oophorectomy,' says Dr Chris Barclay GP with an interest in O&G, Suffolk.
GPs could play a key role in shared HIV care
25 Apr 2012
Primary care teams can make a valuable contribution to counselling, testing and treatment for HIV, a systematic review has shown. This review was limited by various factors. However, it does show that there are no adverse clinical outcomes for HIV counselling, testing and treatment in primary care; also, cost-effectiveness studies were largely in favour. Comments Dr Richard Ma, GP with an interest in sexual health, North London 'The time has come to consider moving to a shared-care model for HIV. However, the challenge of breaking down stigma so that people with HIV disclose their status to their primary healthcare team still remains a barrier for good care in the UK.'
|
Severity of lower urinary tract symptoms linked to central obesity
22 Mar 2012
Waist circumference, a simple measure of central obesity, appears to be predictive of the severity of lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) in men, a study from the United States has found. 'This study emphasises the importance of considering cardiovascular risk and diabetes in men presenting with LUTS and/or ED', writes Dr Jonathan Rees, GPwSI Urology, Bristol. 'There is evidence that increasing exercise and weight loss will lead to an improvement in LUTS and erectile function. Therefore lifestyle advice aiming at these factors should form a routine part of primary care management of these conditions.'
Statins are as beneficial in women as men
21 Mar 2012
A large meta-analysis has shown that statins are just as effective in women as in men for reducing cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality. The analysis included 141,235 patients, 40,275 of whom were women, from studies such as JUPITER, ALLHAT-LLT, ASCOT-LLA, the Heart Protection Study, PROVE-IT and TNT. The trials included were a mixture of primary and secondary prevention studies. 'This study supports the notion that statins are a beneficial intervention in both primary and secondary prevention and that this effect holds true for both sexes,' comments Dr Peter Savill, GP Watercress Medical, Medstead, GPwSI Cardiology, Southampton.
Delayed cord clamping preserves iron status in infants
21 Mar 2012
Babies have a lower risk of developing iron deficiency anaemia at four months when there is a delay in clamping the umbilical cord after delivery, a study from Sweden has shown. A total of 400 term babies were randomised to early cord clamping (within 10 seconds of birth) or delayed clamping (at least three minutes after delivery). Babies were held 20 cm below the level of the perineum to aid flow of blood from the placenta to the baby before division of the cord. At four months, there were no differences in haemoglobin levels between the two groups. However, mean ferritin levels were 117 and 81 µg/L, in delayed and early clamped babies, respectively, a difference of 45%.
Aspirin not warranted for primary prevention
21 Mar 2012
The potential cardiovascular benefits of aspirin are outweighed by the risk of nontrivial bleeding in people without cardiovascular disease (CVD), a meta-analysis has shown. The researchers analysed nine randomised placebo-controlled trials reporting on cardiovascular disease, non-vascular outcomes or death. Each trial contained at least 1,000 participants, mean age at baseline was 57 years and 46% of participants were men.
Use of SSRIs in pregnancy increases risk of persistent pulmonary hypertension in the newborn
21 Mar 2012
A population-based cohort study from the Nordic countries has found that women who take SSRIs during the second half of pregnancy are more than twice as likely to give birth to children with persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn (PPHN). However, the absolute risk remains very low. Data were obtained from national registers of births, deaths and dispensed prescriptions. Exclusion criteria were multiple births and a gestational age of less than 33 weeks. More than 1.6 million infants, born between 1996 and 2007, were included in the study.
Accelerated partner therapy schemes improve treatment rates
21 Mar 2012
Accelerated partner therapy (APT) strategies do appear to expedite partner treatment compared with routine partner notification (PN), a UK-based study has found. The trial involved two urban genitourinary medicine (GUM) clinics: one in central London and another outside London where it is the sole GUM service. Dr Ma considers the messages this of this study for general practice.
|
Burnout is common in GPs
25 Feb 2012
A cross-sectional, postal survey of GPs has found high levels of burnout. The study revealed high scores for emotional exhaustion and depersonalisation in more than four out of ten respondents, and low scores for perceived personal achievement in a third. Dr Phillip Bland, GP with an interest in mental health reflects upon the findings, 'It is suprising that, in the current study, depersonalisation did not appear to be associated with impaired performance.'
Low levels of physical activity reduce MI risk
25 Feb 2012
Leisure time exercise and low to moderate physical activity at work are associated with a reduced risk of myocardial infarction (MI), a large international study across different economic regions has shown. Earlier research had found a link between physical activity during leisure time and cardiovascular disease but the association with work-related activity was less clear. INTERHEART is a case-control study of more than 29,000 people from 52 countries in Europe, Asia, the Middle East, Africa, Australia, and North and South America. Peter Savill comments, 'The take-home message for our patients is clear: the best way to avoid the coronary care unit is to engage in regular physical activity. More importantly, benefits can be seen with even a small daily duration of exercise with any activity being better than none. In a world of spiralling healthcare costs this is an easy and cost-effective intervention which should further empower us in the battle against sedentary lifestyles.'
Should direct renin inhibitors be used in combination therapy with ACE inhibitors or ARBs?
25 Feb 2012
Combining a direct renin inhibitor with ACE inhibitor (ACEI) or angiotensin receptor blocker (ARB) therapy increases the risk of hyperkalaemia, a meta-analysis published in the BMJ has found. When patients are treated with this combination therapy serum potassium levels need to be carefully monitored, the authors caution. The researchers, from Toronto, carried out a systematic review and meta-analysis of ten randomised controlled trials (both published and unpublished), covering 4,814 patients, that compared combined treatment using aliskiren and ACEI or ARB with monotherapy for at least four weeks. The trials provided numerical data on the adverse events of hyperkalaemia and acute kidney injury. A random effects model was used to calculate pooled risk ratios for these outcomes.
Annual IUD checks of little benefit
25 Feb 2012
Regular routine check ups on women fitted with intrauterine contraceptive devices (IUD) do not appear to confer any protection against adverse events, a UK general practice-based study has found. The medical records of women registered with one practice in Rugby, Warwickshire who had had an IUD fitted between 1976 and 2005 were examined. Only women who had a device in place for at least two years with a complete set of legible records covering the time between insertion and removal or study endpoint (March 2007) were included in this retrospective analysis.
Assessing risk of VTE with combined oral contraceptives
25 Feb 2012
Combined oral contraceptive pills (COCPs) containing desogestrel, gestodene or drospirenone appear to confer double the risk of venous thromboembolism (VTE) compared with those containing levonorgestrel, a large population-based study in the BMJ has found. Data on all women in Denmark aged 15-49 years were identified from four national registries during the period 2001-2009. After exclusions for confounders such as malignant disease, pregnancy and coagulopathy almost 1.3 million women with more than 8 million women-years of data were analysed. Around a third had never used the COCP. A total of 4,307 thromboembolic events were recorded in this cohort of which 4,246 were included and 2,847 (67%) were deemed certain cases as anticoagulant use was also confirmed. The analysis controlled for confounders such as BMI, smoking and social class.
Deaths from opioid pain killers soar
25 Feb 2012
The mortality rate from opioid analgesics has increased fourfold over the past decade in the United States, a national study, published in JAMA, has found. Reviewing the study, Dr Jez Thompson concludes, 'This paper clearly identifies rapid growth in the prescribing of opioid analgesics in the United States over the past decade, with a large parallel increase in related morbidity and mortality, leading the authors to claim that death from prescribed opioid pain relievers is now "an epidemic". Prescribers in the UK need to remain acutely aware of the dangers of prescribed opioid analgesics, while safeguarding legitimate access to treatment. This paper echoes current clinical guidance and recommends use of opioid analgesics only in carefully screened and monitored patients when non-opioid treatments have not been effective.
Comparing outcomes in different birth settings
24 Jan 2012
For healthy women with low-risk pregnancies the incidence of adverse perinatal outcomes is low in all birth settings. However, for those who are nulliparous the risk of an adverse outcome appears to be higher for births planned at home, a national cohort study has found. There was also a high intrapartum transfer rate. Over a two-year period nearly 65,000 women ‘attended by an NHS midwife during labour in the planned place of birth’ were enrolled in the Birthplace in England national prospective cohort study. Dr Chris Barclay, GP with an interest in O&G, Suffolk, reviews the study. He concludes: 'So, where is the best place to give birth? The answer appears to be that it depends on the presence of pre-existing risk factors and maternal preference. The outcomes in the midwifery units were very reassuring. However, the significantly higher figures for adverse perinatal outcomes and transfer during or just after labour from home to an obstetric unit in nulliparous cases opting for a home birth is food for thought.'
Which women with GDM are at risk of future diabetes?
24 Jan 2012
Impaired glucose tolerance, low HDL cholesterol and age > 35 were the strongest predictors of developing diabetes in women with gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM), a study from Vienna has found. Commenting on the study, Dr Chris Barclay, GP with an interest in O&G, Suffolk, writes: ' The development of type 2 diabetes appears to be a continuously progressive process which can last for years or even decades. The metabolic stress of pregnancy appears to unmask this tendency temporarily, even though most women will become euglycaemic after delivery. The underlying metabolic disorder for many of these women will however continue to progress. GDM is an independent risk factor for diabetes. The opportunities for timely intervention and prevention here are obvious. Primary care is best placed to offer this help.'
Homelessness is an independent risk factor for mortality
01 Jun 2009
Stroke risk similar in paroxysmal and sustained AF
23 Jan 2008
Current guidelines advise treating paroxysmal AF in the same way as sustained AF but the evidence is weak, with only one retrospective analysis comparing the risk of stroke in patients with paroxysmal AF vs chronic AF (analysis of the SPAF trials, performed 15 years ago and limited to patients treated with aspirin). The ACTIVE W trial showed that warfarin is more effective than aspirin plus clopidogrel for the prevention of vascular events (stroke, embolism, MI and vascular death) in patients with AF. A recent substudy of this trial looked at the risk of stroke in 1,202 patients with paroxysmal AF compared with 5,495 with sustained AF, and the effectiveness of thromboprophylaxis in these patients. ' This substudy has shown that the risk of stroke is similar, irrespective of whether AF is paroxysmal or sustained, and that anticoagulation therapy is equally effective in both groups. Other factors, such as age and cardiovascular comorbidity, remain central to the ultimate choice of thromboprophylaxis in these patients.'
= Paid-up subscribers